Sunday, 26 February 2017

Long range escort fighters in WW11


At first this may seem a slightly strange blog topic. I am a member of the local U3A Science and technology group. Each member gives a presentation usually  1 hour long but twice a year short centred around an object members present. For my next presentation I have chosen this topic. It combines my interest in modern history with aviation technology.

The allied forces in WW11 had diametrically opposed philosophies on bombing. The RAF found that daylight bombing produced huge losses. From early on they switched to night bombing. Because navigation was imprecise this had to be area bombing. Even area bombing demanded development. As the war progressed a number of navigation and operational aids were developed. These aids were very necessary. A detailed study in 1941 revealed that half of all bombs fell more than five miles from their target.

The American philosophy was quite different. They used heavily gunned aircraft and what they thought was a superior bombsight called the Norden sight. Using this approach they thought it would be possible for bombers ( called Flying Fortresses ) to fight their way to targets and then bomb with precision in daylight. Bitter experience showed this was not possible. Firstly German aircraft could inflict big losses on the Fortresses and secondly precision bombing was not possible in the murky north European weather.

What the Americans needed was a long range fighter to escort the bombers to the target. Such an aircraft evolved over several years as the North American P-51 Mustang. ( the US called fighter aircraft “pursuit” planes hence the P designation). The Mustang was originally designed to a British specification at the start of the war. It used a turbocharged Allison engine but only performed well at low altitudes.

The Mustang was designed with a then new laminar flow wing. Essentially this wing was designed for lower turbulence by a flatter aerofoil which gave lower drag. Even so this couldn’t explain why the Mustang was so much more slippery than others. It was found to be a good 30mph faster than other aircraft with the same power. The reason, not realised for years, was that the Mustang had been designed with flat sides rather than the usual rounded ones. This meant it had reduced wave drag in accordance with the area rule. This rule states that minimum transonic  drag requires approximately constant cross sectional area. Where the wings increase the area the fuselage needs to have a smaller cross sectional area to compensate.

Another source of improvement was in the belly radiator of the water cooled engine. Work by NACA established that the lip of its cowling needed to be set away from the airplane structure. Close to the airplane the airflow is static at the surface rising rapidly with distance from the surface. This region is known as the boundary layer. If the radiator takes in boundary layer air it creates turbulence and drag  Also the radiator could be designed so that the waste engine heat expanded air within it giving a small jet thrust.

However the big change came with the use of the licence built Merlin engine with its two stage, two speed supercharger. This boosted the engine power particularly at altitude by about 30%. The revamped Mustang was designated the P-51B or P-51C according to the factory in which it was built. The revised model also had extra fuel tankage in the fuselage.

The final factor in improving the range was the use of drop tanks. These temporary underwing tanks were designed to be dropped when empty enabling the normal fighting capacity to be restored.

The use of the revised Mustang to escort US bombers was extremely successful. The Mustang could fly with the bomber stream as far as Berlin.

The impact of the bombing campaign is still debated but there is no doubt it contributed to ultimate victory.

                                                                                             

No comments:

Post a Comment